login   |    register
Eduard [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEBSITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

In-Box Review
132
Messerschmitt Bf 109E-4
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Boxtop

by: Rowan Baylis [ MERLIN ]


Originally published on:
AeroScale

The second in Eduard's series of 1:32 Bf 109E's has arrived in the shape of the 'E-4. Armed with 20mm cannons in the wings and with the later square-type canopy, the 'E-4 represents the definitive Emil version in many people's eyes.

The kit arrives in an attractive and solid top-opening box (a good job too, because some kind soul had managed to punch right through the corrugated cardboard package containing it somewhere on the way to London!). Despite this rough treatment, all the very well-presented contents arrived intact. The new kit comprises:

152 x pale olive styrene parts (plus 10 unused)
8 x clear styrene parts
52 x etched metal parts, including pre-painted instruments and seat harness
A sheet of die-cut painting masks
Decals for 5 x colour schemes

As you'd expect, the bulk of the parts are identical to Eduard's original Bf 109E-1 reviewed HERE. The moulding is generally nice and crisp, but with just a hint of light flash here and there. Once again, the only sink marks I could find are at the wing roots where the undercarriage attachments are moulded on the inner face, and these are very shallow, taking only a moment or two to take care of. The surface finish is very impressive, with lightly engraved panel lines and subtle embossed rivets, while fabric surfaces have ribs tapes (a little heavily represented).

The first obvious difference between this and the first release is an all-new wing sprue containing parts with the prominent underwing bulges for the 20mm MG FF cannons and revised access panels.

A test fit is pretty good. The main parts are quite thin with a tendency to flex, but actually line up very well. The underside half of the new wing has a slight downward droop towards the tips, which is largely countered by the top panels, but I think I'll still add a "spar" made from a toothpick or something similar to be on the safe side. Interestingly, the fit of the fuselage/wing joint seems to have been adjusted compared with the 'E-1; the roots are tighter, but this time the I did find a gap at the rear joint on the underside that will need filling.

That canopy...
The other big change for the 'E-4 is the inclusion of the "square"-style canopy, and Eduard offer a choice of opening sections, with and without head armour, a separate armoured windscreen, plus a second windscreen with the hole ready drilled for Galland's distinctive telescopic sight. The parts are thin and crystal clear with crisply defined frames. The sliding panels in the main canopy are neatly represented with handles on the inside, along with the clear view panel on the windscreen.

There's seldom been a case where a new kit has become the centre of such an uproar prior to being widely available. All this largely over the canopy, and accusations that it is too tall and thin, with members of the Hyperscale forum queuing up to lambaste the kit, and Eduard equally staunch in its defence.

Of course, reading any criticism inevitably colours how you view something; if you're looking for faults, you'll probably find them. While I certainly wouldn't count myself among the so-called '109 Experten, the kit canopy does look a tad off.

On the height issue, there seem to be two things going on which are probably responsible for the original impression that the canopy is "too tall:

1. Compared with photos, the horizontal frames on the opening section seem a bit narrow, making the vertical side panels seem tall and thin. Beefing up the horizontal frames isn't hard for anyone with a little experience and makes an instant visual improvement.

2. Perhaps it's something to do with tension from the moulding process, but the main section matches the windscreen and rear part at the top, but is marginally narrower at the base. Carefully slicing partway through the canopy inside the top corners (a tool like the recently reviewed RB-SAW fitted with its ultra-fine blade is ideal) will allow the sides to be eased slightly. This is best left to experienced modellers, but of course it's a moot point if you pose the canopy open (as many modellers will) to display the interior detail.

So, is the canopy also slightly narrow at the top? After holding it against dozens of photos I think it probably is, but I won't really know for sure until I get a chance to measure the windscreen on the '109 at Hendon one day.

The acid test is how serious a problem it is. Although some of the harshest critics are declaring the model "fatally flawed" (if ever there was an over-used phrase in modelling...), 95% of people buying the kit would probably never have picked up on the canopy issue if there hadn't been such a fuss. Of course, I'm in a lucky position in receiving a sample gratis, but if ask myself whether it would put me off buying the model, the honest answer is no.

Etched parts
The etched frets are basically unchanged from the first kit, with excellent pre-painted parts for the main instrument panel, consoles and seat harness. A nice point to note is that Eduard have modified the nose radiator cores (the originals were too deep and required trimming to fit).

Instructions and decals
As we've found in the course of our 'E-1 On-Line Build, Eduard's Emil isn't a kit that "builds itself". While I've hit no major problems, it does require a little extra care ensuring everything is lined up correctly and a little adjustment now and again. So, good instructions are important and Eduard's are very clearly drawn and laid out in a logical sequence, with colour matches for Gunze Sangyo paints.

The one real "trap" of the 'E-1 has been addressed; this time it's made very clear that if you build the model with the engine and nose guns installed, you won't be able to fit the cowlings over them. (Actually, while on that note, I would like to see Eduard add an engine "blank" for the closed cowling option to overcome the empty look through the air vents.)

A large stencilling guide is provided, along with full-colour profiles for the 5 featured colour schemes:

A. "<- -", W.Nr. 5344, flown by Maj. Helmut Wick, Geschwaderkommodore JG2, France, November 1940
B. "Yellow 10", W.Nr. 5587, flown by Ofw. Fritz Beeck, 6./JG 51, France, August 1940
C. "Yellow 13", Lt. Josef Eberle, 9./JG 54, The Netherlands, August 1940
D. "< -", W.Nr. 1480, flown by Oblt. Fritz von Werra,Gruppenadjutant II./JG3, France, September 1940
E. "<- -", W.Nr. 5819, flown by Obstlt. Adolf Galland, Geschwaderkommodore JG26, France, December 1940

The decals seem to be excellent quality. 2 sheets are provided; one for the national insignia and unit markings, and a second with a comprehensive set of stencils. The items are thin and glossy, and the carrier film is crystal clear. Swastikas are included in two forms; full and sliced in half.

Conclusion
The furore over the canopy and other perceived issues has to some extent overshadowed the release of this kit. Whether it's down to unrealistic expectations or a bad case of Schadenfreude, it almost seems to have become a "punchbag" that it's fashionable to take a swipe at in some quarters. That's unfair, because no kit is perfect and Eduard's Emil is a huge advance over previous attempts in this scale in almost every way. I'm left thinking that some modellers would be hard to please with anything; for them the only good kit is the one that's yet to be produced - anything else is a disappointment for some reason or other.

In the end, only you can decide how much of a problem the canopy is for you. Aftermarket alternatives will no doubt appear, but I expect by far the majority of modellers will be perfectly happy with the kit parts. Meanwhile, I'm thoroughly enjoying building the 'E-1 and I confidently expect the new 'E-4 to build into an equally impressive model.

Please remember, when contacting retailers or manufacturers, to mention that you saw their products highlighted here - on AEROSCALE.
SUMMARY
Highs: Highly detailed, with excellent surface finish. Very good decals for 5 colour schemes.
Lows: A question hanging over the canopy dimensions.
Verdict: Eduard's 1:32 scale Bf 109s are beautifully designed and detailed, but not suitable for total beginners. The possibly over-egged canopy question has inevitably soured the water somewhat with the latest release of what is still a very fine kit.
Percentage Rating
85%
  Scale: 1:32
  Mfg. ID: 3003
  Suggested Retail: $ 74.95
  Related Link: 
  PUBLISHED: May 20, 2009
  NATIONALITY: Germany
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 88.04%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 88.44%

Our Thanks to Eduard!
This item was provided by them for the purpose of having it reviewed on this KitMaker Network site. If you would like your kit, book, or product reviewed, please contact us.

View Vendor Homepage  |  More Reviews  

About Rowan Baylis (Merlin)
FROM: NO REGIONAL SELECTED, UNITED KINGDOM

I've been modelling for about 40 years, on and off. While I'm happy to build anything, my interests lie primarily in 1/48 scale aircraft. I mostly concentrate on WW2 subjects, although I'm also interested in WW1, Golden Age aviation and the early Jet Age - and have even been known to build the occas...

Copyright 2019 text by Rowan Baylis [ MERLIN ]. All rights reserved.



Comments

Hi Rowan, Nice review! I have seen the kit in the flesh lately and, while I don't consider myself a rivet counter neither, I too think that the canopy is a bit off. I wouldn't be surprised if at some point Eduard will do a correction. Wait and see... Jean-Luc
MAY 20, 2009 - 06:25 PM
I'm not sure they will Jean-Luc . They posted a letter on their site stating the canopy is fine and will remain as is . It has gotten a lot flak over this issue , but you never know ............... Great re-view , now only if I did 32 scale ...........
MAY 20, 2009 - 06:59 PM
Well some good news for Eduard...Italeri have released the Reggiane Re 2002 and the Hyperscale boys seem to have completely forgotten the Eduard Bf109 for now. As for me it makes no difference anyway, the E-1 is the one i wanted and the canopy on that one looks fine to me. I certainly don't object to people giving due critisism to a model kit and pointing out it's flaws as they see it. Merlin did that in the correct way in his review. But much of this whole thing smells of a lot of people that don't actually know faeces from apple-sauce, and who haven't even seen the model kit for real, all just jumping on the good ol' bandwagon. It's no wonder Eduard's come back sounding a bit angry.
MAY 23, 2009 - 01:27 AM
Very well put Andrew ! I'm by far any kind of expert on WW2 subjects , but it has been pointed out before , If it looks like a 109 then it is a 109 . I do feel that Eduard has out done them self on this kit . The detail of the parts are very well done . Build out of the box it will be one fine looking model ! Now if they would just do one in 48 scale ..................
MAY 23, 2009 - 04:37 AM
Hi all, This is what Eduard have wrote in their new newsletter of june: "The canopy for our Bf109E-4 is, in fact, narrower than it should be. Since our E-4 canopy was an extension of the E-3, I would say that we erroneously chose the point at which the corner of the newer canopy is located. Unfortunately, we located said point at the halfway mark of the radius of the E-3 segment that forms the top of the canopy, rather than locating it in the extended sides of the canopy walls. This mistake unfortunately slipped through QC, which is, to an extent, the result of using the E-3 as the basis from which to develop the E-4. So, we will fix the canopy problem, but it will be in the future releases of the E-4 and the E-7, and likewise for the Bf109F-2 and F-4 that are currently under development. Of course, the correction will also be implemented on the 1/48th scale Bf109E that we are preparing for next year." So what do we learn from that: - Nobody is perfect! - Eduard will correct the canopy in futur releases, however nothing is said about the current release (will they replace the wrong canopy parts?). - They plan to do the F variant in 1/32 scale as well. - They will do a 109 E in 1/48 scale next year. I'm already impatient to see the bonuses of the Royal Class box... Jean-Luc
JUN 06, 2009 - 01:04 AM
Hi J-L many thanks for the pointers to the newsletter. The 1/32 might be a good Idea, but i think Hasegawa will be first, now that Vladimir has announced it. Wee'll see if the market can provide enough sale for both products. Lets hope Eduard will extend the 1/48 scale Bf 109 line forward and not backwards, i.e. Bf 109A to E-1 I do not think they can beat the Tamiya kit (I'd love to be proven wrong in this though). The Hasegawa kit Bf 109F gets old and has some shape issues (nothing I do care about much, but they are there), so a new Czech approach is also welcome. I hope they try to get some of the Bf109-nuts on board to avoid further mistakes. The I-net will spread such news fast and several kits/companies already had their hands (and other body parts) burned ... BTW a LOT more interesting stuff in that Newsletter! cheers Steffen
JUN 06, 2009 - 02:48 AM
   

What's Your Opinion?


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Parts_1
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Parts_2
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Parts_3
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Parts_4
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Parts_5
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Parts_6
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Parts_7
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Etch_1
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Etch_2
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Colours_
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Colours_1
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Colours_2
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Decals_1
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Decals_2
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Surface_1
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Surface_2
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Canopy_1
  • Ed_Bf109E-4_Canopy_2