login   |    register
ICM Holding [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEBSITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

In-Box Review
1144
Tupolev Tu-144
Tupolev Tu-144 Supersonic Transport
  • move

by: Is a secret [ JESSIE_C ]


Originally published on:
AeroScale

History

The Tu-144 was to be the Soviet Union's entry into the high-prestige word of supersonic passenger travel. At the beginning of the 1960s, supersonic transports were expected to be the way of air travel in the future. Every industrialised nation was either involved with planning one, or enviously looking on. The SST was the prestige project. In the Soviet Union, the design bureau of Andrei Tuploev was assigned the task of developing the aircraft. Tupolev's son Alexei was chosen to head the project. Tupolev chose to develop the aircraft in two stages. The first would be an aerodynamic prototype to prove the delta wing concept and aerodynamics, with the fully-developed aircraft to follow along later. This allowed the Soviets to score a propaganda victory by flying the prototype on Dec 31st, 1968 even though it was much smaller and quite different from the aircraft's final configuration. The Tu-144 fell victim to the Soviet Government's indifference to civil aviation, and was handicapped by its politically driven introduction into service before its flight testing and development were complete. The aircraft put into service were handicapped by their engines' high fuel consumption, and by cabin noise levels that were embarrassingly loud. After several inflight equipment failures that were kept from being disasters only by the extreme professionalism of the flight crews, the Soviet Government, not wishing to have a propaganda disaster on their hands, suspended the passenger service less than a year after it began.

The Tu-144 was always in the shadow of Concorde, and its public perception never recovered from the 1973 Paris Airshow disaster where the second development aircraft crashed while attempting to avoid a French Air Force Mirage that may have approached too closely. The exact circumstances of this crash have never been made completely clear. In the latter half of the 1990s, RA-77114 was rebuilt using a set of engines from a Tu-160 and used as a flying laboratory by NASA and several Russian design companies. It made a series of 27 flights exploring the mechanics of supersonic flight. The data obtained from these flights will be kept for use in future supersonic designs.


First Impressions

The kit is packed very tightly into its long narrow box. It's quite large for a supersonic airliner, noticeably larger than Concorde, and the model is quite complicated. It is moulded in a slightly tan grey plastic on 6 sprues plus one of clear for the windows and stand. The plastic has a satin finish, and is soft and easy to work with. The kit depicts an early production TU-144. The Tu-144D's Kolesov RD-36-51 engines are not included, nor are the Kuznetsov NK-321s that powered the Tu-144LL project of the late 1990s. These may be borrowed from a Zvezda or Trumpeter Tu-160


Fuselage

The fuselage is two halves from cockpit to tail. The cabin windows are open, with clear parts provided for them. The cockpit windows are a two piece cockpit cab cover similar to a Heller or Minicraft cockpit, but the two parts make for a tricky glue join in the clear plastic. It would have been simpler to have a one piece cockpit. The panel lines are very fine, nicely engraved and match up well. The vertical fin is moulded into the right fuselage half. The drooping nose is separate, with a clear visor cover. The fuselage is moulded to show the nose drooped. If you want to show yours raised, you will have to trim off the mounting tab under the cockpit. The characteristic canard foreplanes may be mounted extended or retracted. They were often extended when the aircraft was on the ground with the nose lowered, although the aircraft were just as often parked with the nose up and canards retracted. The fuselage halves in my copy are slightly warped, making joining them together a challenge. I may resort to internal bracing to hold the shape properly

Wings

The wings are each comprised of a one piece lower section and upper right and left halves. The elevons and their actuators are separate. There are 5 ejector pin towers left over inside the lower wing section which must be trimmed down in order for the wings to fit properly. Take care not to trim out the circular pedestals nearby; those are needed to establish the correct wing thickness. The elevons have static discharge wicks moulded into their trailing edges. They are quite delicate while at the same time being out of scale. Care will have to be taken to ensure they are not broken off during construction.

Empennage

Since this aircraft was a tailless delta, there is no empannage as such to discuss.

Engines

The engines are quite complicated, and include a section of the bottom of the wing centre section. The intakes, including the main landing gear bay, are built from top and bottom sections and inserted into the main engine fairings. Cleaning up the gap should be done before gluing the intake assembly into the engine nacelle. There is an intake guide vane and boundary layer separator plate to insert into the intakes. At the aft end, the nozzles of the Kuznetsov NK-144 engines and a curved section slide into the engine nacelle. The two engine nacelles mate together to form the lower centre section of the wing and a portion of the aft fuselage. Take care to achieve a correct fit in this complicated assembly

Landing gear

The landing gear struts and wheels are finely moulded and nicely detailed. The main struts are fairly complicated, and ICM has included an addendum sheet to the instructions showing their recommended assembly sequence. The nose gear strut is similarly well detailed and has 6 small clear landing lights. They could use some brake lines and whatever else the modeller likes, but will look good without them. The wheels themselves are properly thick and the detail moulded into the hubs is very good. There is an option for raised gear, and a stand is provided. As with all 1/144 kits, the gear doors are fairly thick but the real aircraft's main gear doors were quite thick. The nose gear doors are a trifle too thick, but there is no significant detail inside them, so they may be sanded down if you wish. ICM did make an effort to get the edges thin.

Accuracy

I don't compare models to drawings or published measurements. When assembled it looks like a Tu-144

Decals and Markings

The decal sheet provides for the only two Tu-144s that flew scheduled passenger services. CCCP-77109 flew the first commercial service between Moscow and Alma Ata (now Almaty, Kazakhstan) in November of 1977. CCCP-77110 was the display aircraft at the Paris Air show in June of 1977. Apart from the registrations, the only differences are the АЕРОФЛОТ titles and the Paris Air Show display numbers. The decals are printed in ICM's familiar matte finish. They have good registration, but the edges of the cheatlines are slightly blurry. No window decals are provided.

test fit

I removed the major parts from the sprues and taped them together to test the fit. The long fuselage seam is going to be a challenge, as is the very complicated fit of the engine nacelles into the lower wing and aft fuselage. When placed beside my Revell Concorde, the size of the Tu-144 becomes apparent. When comparing the wings, remember that the Tupolev's elevons have not been fitted.

The real thing


CCCP-77110 in Paris, June 1977.

CCCP-77110 preserved in Ulyanovsk, looking a little worse for wear after enduring 30 Russian winters.

Please remember, when contacting retailers or manufacturers, to mention that you saw their products highlighted here - on AEROSCALE.
SUMMARY
Highs: Delicate parts with a lot of detail for 1/144 scale. Fine engraving and a subject that hasn't been done to death.
Lows: Warped fuselage and complicated assembly make this one a little more difficult than your usual airliner. No window decals.
Verdict: The only other Tu-144s in this scale are the very expensive Bra.Z resin kit or the nearly impossible to find Entex kit of the prototype.
Percentage Rating
90%
  Scale: 1:144
  Mfg. ID: 14401
  Suggested Retail: C$46.99
  Related Link: 
  PUBLISHED: Mar 07, 2012
  NATIONALITY: Russia
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 90.12%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 84.66%

About Is a secret (Jessie_C)
FROM: BRITISH COLUMBIA, CANADA

Copyright 2019 text by Is a secret [ JESSIE_C ]. All rights reserved.



Comments

Would love to see the review.i just get an error message
MAR 06, 2012 - 04:09 PM
There's this little button you have to click to make the review go live. Guess who forgot to click it? It should work now...
MAR 06, 2012 - 05:17 PM
   

What's Your Opinion?


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move